Colorado officials advise school districts on girls' sports

Department of Education provides guidance on transgender athletes and voter-approved Proposition 134
Carbonatix Pre-Player Loader

Audio By Carbonatix

(The Center Square) - The Colorado Department of Education sent every school district a guidance document this week on implementing Proposition 134, which was approved by voters in the Nov. 3 election.


The measure would require all public school athletic teams to be designated as male- or female-only based on a student’s biological sex, unless the sport is designated as allowing open participation from anyone. 


The proposition, which passed by 52%, is set to be implemented on Jan. 1. The guidance document was sent to all school districts in the state on Tuesday to help schools implement the policy. 


Critics, such as One Colorado, an LGBTQ+ advocacy organization, argue Prop. 134 unfairly targets transgender students, whereas proponents point to the differences and advantages biological males have over female students. 


Nadine Bridges, the executive director of One Colorado, told The Center Square in an email that the organization is working closely with the newly elected members of the executive branch to “prevent harm to LGBTQIA+ students and protect their rights to be safe and supported at school.”


The guidance document states that the proposition could present challenges for some schools and districts. “Many questions are left unresolved by the new statutory language, and future litigation or legislation may attempt to resolve issues presented by the new law.” 


Following the passage of Prop. 134, Gov.-elect Phil Weiser told media outlets in a post-election interview that this ballot measure, among others, would require a “hard look” prior to their implementation. Weiser, a Democrat who is currently the state attorney general, has been an outspoken critic of the proposition on numerous occasions, previously telling The Center Square that he supports “equality for all” and worries that the new law could damage existing protections for transgender students. 


The proposition restricts students’ sports participation on teams to align with their biological sex, but CDE’s guidance does not require verification of a student’s biological sex and discourages intrusive eligibility checks. 


The guidance document states, “CDE does not read the measure to require physical examinations, genetic testing, medical documentation or parent affirmations to determine the child’s "biological reproductive system" and, therefore, whether the child is male or female as defined under Article 60.” It also says that requiring such could “implicate the constitutional rights of students.” 


The Colorado Department of Education acknowledged it is the governing body tasked with enforcing Prop. 134. But it added that a school or district can demonstrate compliance by simply enacting a policy that is consistent with the statutory provisions.


Although students are required to submit a doctor-approved physical examination before enrolling in a school-based sports team, state law prohibits schools from collecting birth certificates. Colorado law also permits the issuance of new birth certificates that align with an individual’s gender identity. 


More strikingly, the department’s guidance explains that it will not require schools or districts to implement a complaint process if there are alleged violations of the statute. It explicitly recommends against creating such a process to prevent bullying and harassment of LGBTQ+ students.


Instead, the CDE recommends that schools and districts create their own plans for how to respond to these concerns in a way that complies with both state and federal anti-discrimination and student privacy laws. But the department doesn't give any specific guidance on how to do that.


Additionally, the proposition provides that the Colorado High School Activities Association does not have any enforcement authority.


“The measure assigns enforcement for school districts to the Colorado commissioner of education," said Brad Cochi, the association’s communications lead.


"Like every member school, CHSAA must comply with the new law, and we are reviewing our bylaws and procedures to ensure they are consistent with it," Cochi told The Center Square.


The Center Square reached out to the Colorado Department of Education, which declined to comment further on the guidance document.


Earlier this year, the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights issued a warning against Jefferson County Public Schools, a district that sits in the south-metro Denver area and borders the entrance to the Rocky Mountains. The DOJ cited alleged violations of a federal executive order, titled “Keeping Men out of Women’s Sports.” In its letter, the department said the district has continued to not comply with federal Title IX protections. 


Title IX came out of the Education Amendments of 1972. It was created to fill the hole in the Civil Rights Act, which did not include protection from any sex-based discrimination. Since then, compliance with Title IX has been a requirement for public schools across the country in order to receive federal funding. 


The federal government has threatened to withhold roughly $50 million in education funding – which comes out to about $690 per student – over the alleged violations. The government alleged that the district allowed male students to participate in female sports, occupy female bathrooms and locker rooms, and share overnight accommodations with females on school trips that aligned with the student’s gender identity. 


The district refutes those claims, saying the federal government based its warning on flawed information. The Department of Education's letter said it found males on girls' teams, but the district says some of them were coaches, managers, trainers or mascots. 


Devra Ashby, Jefferson County school district’s communications executive director, told The Center Square that the district plans to update its existing policies that protect discrimination against transgender students. But Ashby added that current policies will stay in place until Prop. 134 goes into effect on Jan. 1.


The implementation of Proposition 134 also raises questions about how the measure will interact with Colorado's existing anti-discrimination laws, including the Kelly Loving Act, which was signed by Democratic Gov. Jared Polis in 2025. It expanded legal protections for transgender individuals, requiring schools that adopt or enforce chosen-name policies to accommodate students who use names different from their legal names, including those associated with gender identity.


Proposition 134, meanwhile, establishes athletic eligibility requirements based on biological sex rather than gender identity, potentially raising questions about how schools will reconcile the new participation restrictions with existing state protections against discrimination based on gender identity and gender expression.


The district acknowledged that some legal questions remained unanswered, but the state department’s guidance “provides a framework for districts to comply with the new law while upholding existing student protections.” 


Existing transgender student protections from the district come from Policy Regulation JB-R2, which sought to foster a safe and discrimination-free environment for transgender students. 


Regarding the lawsuit, Ashby said, “The students identified in the federal Office for Civil Rights' findings were not occupying competitive roster positions on girls’ athletic teams. We will continue to protect the privacy of individual students and will not disclose information about their gender identity or athletic eligibility.” 


“Our commitment remains unchanged," the Jefferson County school district official added. "Every Jeffco student deserves a safe, welcoming and inclusive learning environment where they are treated with dignity and respect.” 


 

 

Salem News Channel Today

Sponsored Links

On Air & Up Next

  • Overnight Drive
    1:00AM - 4:00AM
     
    Steve Sommers is LIVE! every weeknight with his call-in talk show — a   >>
     
  • This Morning with Gordon Deal
     
    Go beyond the headlines with the day's first look at news and business news from the U.S. and around the world
     
  • O’Connor & Company
    5:00AM - 8:00AM
     
    From 6:00–9:00 a.m. Eastern, O’Connor & Company will drive coverage of the   >>
     
  • The Mike Gallagher Show
    8:00AM - 11:00AM
     
    Mike Gallagher is one of the most listened-to radio talk show hosts in America.   >>
     
  • The Alex Marlow Show
    11:00AM - 12:00PM
     
    In a time when political establishments, globalist bureaucracies, and   >>
     

See the Full Program Guide